The Great Spark Plug Debate

[solarite_guy]

The Great Spark Plug Debate: Separating Fact From Opinion

(Note: At the end I will mention one item I have a partial disagreement with)

http://www.enginelabs.com/engine-tec...-from-opinion/

By Jeff Smith February 23, 2018

There’s a war being fought out over the internet right now – and the first victim in this explosive war of words is the truth. So we decided to talk to Director of Engineering for Autolite, Jerry Reeves, who not only knows this subject really well, but is a car guy, too. What we’ve learned will hopefully dispel many of the myths and old wives’ tales surrounding the spark plug.

One of the most contentious areas of disagreements surrounds fine-wire spark plugs. It seems that everyone has an opinion about platinum and iridium plugs compared to the standard copper-core version. We’ll just start by saying that there’s a good chance that whatever you’ve read or been told about fine-wire plugs is probably incorrect.

(I haven't figured out how to resize images yet, so I will provide links)

http://cdn.speednik.com/wp-content/b...-28_520405.jpg

This compares an extended-nose plug (left) to a standard-reach plug (right). Note how much longer the extended-reach plug’s ground strap is compared to the standard-reach. For street engines, the extended-nose is good for part-throttle efficiency. The short- reach is far better for high output engines where the longer ground strap could get hot enough to cause pre-ignition.

The Basics

First, we should define the terms “detonation” and “pre-ignition”. We’ll start with detonation, which is an uncontrolled combustion pressure spike that can occur at any time, even before the spark plug fires. This can occur as a result of high cylinder temperature and/or pressure that causes the air and fuel to self-ignite. Pre-ignition is where combustion initiates before the spark plug fires as the result of an extremely hot, glowing ignition source in the chamber. Many times this is traced (but not limited) to a long ground strap used on an extended-nose spark plug. If you pay close attention, you’ll notice that most racing plugs do not employ extended-nose center electrodes. This keeps the ground electrode short, minimizing its path to the cylinder head where the heat can be dissipated.

http://cdn.speednik.com/wp-content/b...-27_642556.jpg

Fine-wire plugs like this Denso Iridium (left) requires much less voltage to fire the same spark plug gap versus a standard copper-core plug (right). This Denso plug is called a U-Groove referencing the U-shaped ground strap

We should also define the term “copper core” when talking about spark plugs. Copper is used as the core material for nearly all spark plugs. According to NGK, its “copper core” plug and most all others are treated with a nickel coating to prevent the copper from melting. This applies to fine-wire plugs as well, which use a copper core to improve conductivity.

A spark plug’s heat range is a major factor in engine tuning, and as a result, should be given the attention that it deserves. The heat range is established by the distance the heat in the center electrode and insulator ceramic must travel before it contacts the steel body of the spark plug. A “hot” spark plug lengthens the depth of the ceramic which lengthens the distance from the center electrode end of the plug to where it contacts the spark plug shell. From there, the heat is dissipated into the cylinder head and eventually into the cooling system. The path for heat to escape from the center ceramic to the plug’s steel body is at the very bottom of the steel shell. Cold spark plugs offer a shorter heat path to the shell. Most competition engine builders commonly choose a colder heat range plug to prevent possible engine damage.

http://cdn.speednik.com/wp-content/b...-17_271822.jpg

The addition of precious metal in the center electrode has nothing to do with the heat range of a spark plug. The heat range is designed into the relationship of the ceramic to the plug body. The plug on the left is a cold plug with a shallow ceramic depth. The plug on the right is a much hotter plug with the ceramic connecting with the outer shell much deeper.

Dispelling The Spark Plug Myths

Fine-wire plugs were designed for use in late model engines that are tasked with the seemingly ridiculous goal of lasting for 100,000 miles in a production engine. Reeves says the single- and double-platinum were employed strictly as a measure to increase the durability of the spark plugs. The move to iridium plugs could potentially be a performance advantage.

An iridium plug uses an extremely fine wire (0.5 to 0.6mm or 0.019-0.023-inch) that, because of its small size, can reduce the required coil voltage by as much as 20-percent. This means there’s an even greater reservoir of voltage at the coil if the cylinder requires it. Fine-wire iridium plugs can improve the combustion process even if there is a high level of exhaust gas dilution—built-in EGR—as with engines with long-duration camshafts with a greater amount of overlap.

http://cdn.speednik.com/wp-content/b...-27_974569.jpg

We removed the threads on these two plugs to illustrate heat range. The plug on the left is a hotter heat range than the plug on the right. Note how the hot plug’s ceramic has a longer path from the tip of the plug to where the ceramic contacts the plug’s shell and then to the head. The colder plug on the right has a much shorter path for the heat to travel; it pulls heat more efficiently from the plug tip so it will not burn off carbon as easily.

We’ve seen statements from tuners claiming that fine-wire plugs run “hotter” than normal plugs and that you should avoid fine-wire plugs especially in supercharged or turbocharged applications. Reeves points out that the facts support the exact opposite conclusion. As an example, the supercharged production 2018 Dodge Hellcat—which makes 707 hp from its 6.2L Hemi—specs an iridium spark plug. If you want another example, there’s the 350 hp Focus RS turbocharged four-cylinder Ford engine that pushes as much as 25 psi of boost, and it also employs an iridium plug.

Let’s look at some facts that support why fine-wire plugs are a good choice for a performance engine.

A commonly-held, yet mistaken conclusion is that the center electrode contributes to pre-ignition because iridium and platinum are poor conductors of heat. While the fine wires are indeed poor conductors, Reeves tells us that the addition of the precious-metal portion of the center electrode contributes only a small amount of heat and is not a source of pre-ignition.

http://cdn.speednik.com/wp-content/b...-30_440051.jpg

This is a used plug from a small-block Chevy that had started out with roughly 0.040-inch gap and the copper core has worn to 0.050-inch. A wider gap increases the load on the ignition system, demanding higher voltage. Replacing this with a fine-wire plug would allow running a decent plug gap and still offer the potential for improved combustion.

The copper core does transfer a significant amount of heat. Reeves emphasized that the heat range rating of a copper-core spark plug and an iridium plug will be the same and that it is the tip (overall) length of the center ceramic that determines any plug’s actual heat range. The center electrode’s precious-metal material does not contribute to the heat range, nor is it a factor with regard to pre-ignition.



A common question with performance engines is selecting a spark plug heat range. A tuner will often spec a heat range one to three steps colder than the stock heat range. This often is a result of dyno test data where the colder plug appears to work just fine. But then on the street, this cold plug fouls sooner because there is insufficient heat to burn off the carbon deposits.

We recently added Holley’s Sniper EFI to a 468ci big-block Chevy, and while it seemed to idle well, we used an EMS 5-gas exhaust gas analyzer to help us dial in the timing and fuel. Then we discovered the engine still had the cold spark plugs in it from the previous year’s dyno test. The plugs were two steps colder than the stock heat range and appeared dark and soot-colored. We recorded the idle quality numbers from the EMS analyzer and then installed stock heat range plugs that were two steps hotter and were of a single-platinum configuration. The engine did not appear to misfire with the cold plugs.

The change to the hotter plugs improved the idle quality only slightly by reducing the unburned hydrocarbon (HC) count along with a slight improvement in CO2 which is an indicator of combustion efficiency. So the combination of increasing the heat range, and the platinum center electrode contributed to making the engine idle better, cleaner, and more efficiently.

http://cdn.speednik.com/wp-content/b...-54_202032.jpg

We’ve also run across opinions claiming that a copper-core plug will somehow burn off carbon deposits more efficiently than fine-wire plugs. This is also incorrect and relates back to our earlier point that a fine-wire electrode has no impact on heat range. Spark plugs with a hotter heat range will burn off carbon deposits more easily than a colder plug.

“As an example, an Autolite copper 105 versus an XP Iridium 105 will have identical ceramic temperatures and the carbon burn off will be the same,” says Reeves.

http://cdn.speednik.com/wp-content/b...-16_391754.jpg

A spark plug’s reach is defined as the length of the threads. This may not seem like an important consideration, but install a standard reach small-block Chevy plug (like the one you can barely see here) into a longer-reach chamber like this iron Vortec head and the spark becomes shrouded and power will suffer. We’ve seen a 20 hp loss from incorrectly installed plugs like this on a 500 hp engine.

The way an engine is used has a big effect on choosing the proper heat range. An example might be a dual purpose street/drag car, especially if it uses a power-adder like nitrous or supercharging. For subdued street driving, a standard heat range, extended-nose spark plug would be a great choice, but only if the engine is not called upon to make maximum power. That’s walking a very fine line.

Reeves makes an excellent point. “I wouldn’t want someone to run a projected tip, standard automotive plug in a 1,200 horsepower, 32 psi LS engine because it’s street-driven.”

For high-load, max-cylinder-temperature track excursions, a colder, standard nose or even surface gap plug is the wisest choice.

http://cdn.speednik.com/wp-content/b...-44_615435.jpg

MSD’s Spark Guard is dielectric grease used to protect the boot from sticking to the spark plug and minimize errant spark leakage. Do not smear it on the connector to the spark plug. This grease is an insulator not a conductor. Place a small amount around the inside of the boot. Your ignition system will thank you for your attention to detail.

As power from late model engines continues to escalate, selecting a spark plug that will live and not contribute to problems becomes a much more difficult assignment. High horsepower engines and especially supercharged, nitrous, and turbocharged powerplants making four-digit horsepower are increasingly susceptible to pre-ignition. For tuning these engines, it’s best to start with a very cold plug with a short ground electrode. Ground electrode length is not a function of heat range. So for power-adder applications, its best to avoid the projected nose spark plugs, keeping the ground strap length short.





Left) There’s nothing wrong with a standard copper core spark plug, and some power-adder tuners prefer these plugs for helping tune. These plugs are inexpensive and should be considered a consumable. This is an Autolite race plug that is also configured with a side gap. (Right) This melted plug was destroyed when the nitrous system went lean. While it is a platinum plug – that had little to do with its failure. The plug melted because of excessive heat in the chamber. Likely the air-fuel ratio was excessively lean.

Crossing The Gap

While spark plug gap does not have a direct effect on timing, excessive gap in a power adder application can easily cause engine misfire. While a standard gap of 0.035-inch works well for naturally-aspirated engines, if the plug wires are in good shape and the ignition is strong enough, many naturally-aspirated engines might benefit from a slightly wider gap of 0.045 to perhaps 0.050-inch.

http://cdn.speednik.com/wp-content/b...-43_667922.jpg

Spark plug companies don’t recommend anti-seize on threads because it lowers the torque required to install the plug. Torquing the plugs to the published spec with anti-seize overtorques the plug which potentially could break the internal seal between the insulator and the shell, creating a leak path. So it’s best to install spark plugs dry.

Conversely, supercharged, turbocharged or nitrous applications will demand a narrower plug gap of 0.025 to 0.030-inch.
Another idea that can offer potential advantages is a cut-back ground electrode where the ground strap is cut or filed to uncover the center electrode. With less mass in the strap, it does not remove as much heat from the initial flame kernel. As the ground strap length increases, this adds more mass and can slow the growth of the initial flame kernel. Cut back ground straps are also useful in applications where a standard strap may interfere with the piston dome.





(Left) Often, a projected-nose plug (shown on left) with a long ground strap can build excessive heat and cause pre-ignition issues. Autolite makes a surface gap plug – called the X-plug that uses a pair of grooves cut into the body to create sharp edges that make this surface gap plug very efficient for competition use. This is a cold heat range plug so may not be a wise choice for every day street use. (Right) Sometimes a shorter spark plug can improve clearance with tight-fitting headers. These three spark plugs are all tapered seat, projected nose yet when lined up at the seat, they are three different lengths. So you might look around for a shorter plug to create more clearance for the spark plug boot.

The disadvantage is this will concentrate the spark on one side of the center electrode. With a traditional copper-core plug, the center electrode will wear much more quickly and the gap will increase. This is a trick that is perhaps best left to short-duration race engines. Another option for power-adder applications is to choose a surface-gap plug. Autolite offers the X-series of plugs that has slots cut in the end of the plug, creating sharp edges that make it easier for the spark to jump the gap.

http://cdn.speednik.com/wp-content/b...-54_735759.jpg

To increase the plug gap using a simple gap tool, place the end of the ground electrode in the hole and carefully push down on the end of tool. Reeves warns that a too-wide gap can create the situation where the spark fires sideways to the edge of the plug. While the spark still occurs, it can retard the timing by as much as two degrees.

In Conclusion

There is much more material regarding spark plug design and usage than we can cover here in one story. Even with late-model fuel injection and data logging, reading a spark plug is still a viable art that is an important part of tuning. Hopefully we’ve managed to dispel a few myths and provide facts that you can use to make your next tuning decisions a bit more accurate.

My final comment, regarding anti-seize. I can understand why it was mentioned to avoid anti-seize. However, situations exist where it should be used. For example alloy heads where the plugs are constantly being pulled and read. Alloy blocks where the clutch or auto transmission is constantly being pulled. Alloy heads where the plugs are staying in place for 100,000 miles.

Also, if you checked the link I am not a big fan of the way the anti-seize is being applied. However, I do like that they should keeping the anti-seize away from the end of the threads.

However, use it with the cautions mentioned.

[GO FURTHER]

Bottom line is:

If your car is stock, always use OEM replacements which will be of the correct heat range, often with the required pre-set gap.... And you are safe to go.

Like fuel filters, oil filters, and coils, I always stick to OEM parts.... It's just not worth taking the risk with certain items.

[FTE217]

I'm also a Autolite user but no matter good read in general on spark plugs.

[csv8]

Excellent read.. even my i20 uses Iridium plugs.

[Charliewool]

Top post that!
Should be a sticky somewhere here!

[pyrex]

Originally Posted by GO FURTHER

Bottom line is:

If your car is stock, always use OEM replacements which will be of the correct heat range, often with the required pre-set gap.... And you are safe to go.

Like fuel filters, oil filters, and coils, I always stick to OEM parts.... It's just not worth taking the risk with certain items.

What plugs and more importantly what plug gap do you run at 17psi?

[FTE217]

Originally Posted by GO FURTHER

Bottom line is:

If your car is stock, always use OEM replacements which will be of the correct heat range, often with the required pre-set gap.... And you are safe to go.

Like fuel filters, oil filters, and coils, I always stick to OEM parts.... It's just not worth taking the risk with certain items.

Well yes and no.
My cars only use some OEM parts whilst under warranty.
Rip off for starters, I can afford them but its the principle.
A good high end Aftermarket brand is the same/similar and as good.
Most of them come from OES manufacturers so can't see why not saving 50% at least.

[GO FURTHER]

Originally Posted by pyrex

What plugs and more importantly what plug gap do you run at 17psi?

Genuine Iridium plugs (Part No: AGSP 22YE11) recommended for the FG Turbo, which cost $42 for a set of six.

Set at 1.1mm spark gap.

[roKWiz]

I bought iridium plugs (25 bucks a pop) just to see what the fuss was all about for the stock XF X flow, a couple of thousand K's so far, I haven't noticed any difference to standard.

[pyrex]

Don't you think 1.1mm is too big for that boost level?

[GO FURTHER]

Originally Posted by pyrex

Don't you think 1.1mm is too big for that boost level?

Rob Herrod recommended leaving it at that when he tuned the car.

[JIm260]

I used to use a hotter plug in the front cylinder than in the rear cylinder of my "78 900 SS Ducati.

Cheers
JIm

[nstg8a]

We just had our Subaru serviced, nice little surprise when we get back and find out his service required new plugs. $200 later for four iridium plugs. Will be paying more attention when the next service is due...

[arronm]

Originally Posted by pyrex

Don't you think 1.1mm is too big for that boost level?

Yes 0.7-0.8mm for that boost.

Fit these. genuine ford. My tuner uses these in low 9 second FG. Pregapped to 0.7. Can install in BA BF FG...

https://www.ebay.com.au/itm/GENUINE-...kAAOxypNtSgJrp

[arronm]

Originally Posted by GO FURTHER

Genuine Iridium plugs (Part No: AGSP 22YE11) recommended for the FG Turbo, which cost $42 for a set of six.

Set at 1.1mm spark gap.

You cant run 1.1mm at 17psi. Spark will blow out.

Even BF -turbo with 7-9psi run 0.9mm gap stock

[au350hp]

Excellent post. I refuse to pay the ridiculous prices for Iridium which only allow longer use, there is no power advantage I am aware of regardless. I use $5 plugs from Bosch in the 220kw Windsor & I change them every 10,000kms. I prefer new plugs more often than expensive ones less often, but I change everything before its recommended, oil, filters, pads etc

[solarite_guy]

Originally Posted by JIm260

I used to use a hotter plug in the front cylinder than in the rear cylinder of my "78 900 SS Ducati.

Cheers
JIm

Out of curiosity, did you jet that cylinder differently from the rear as well?

[Bossxr8]

Originally Posted by arronm

Yes 0.7-0.8mm for that boost.

Fit these. genuine ford. My tuner uses these in low 9 second FG. Pregapped to 0.7. Can install in BA BF FG...

https://www.ebay.com.au/itm/GENUINE-...kAAOxypNtSgJrp

What's the advantage of using e-gas plugs, different heat range?

[arronm]

Pre-gapped.

[Bossxr8]

Originally Posted by arronm

Pre-gapped.

So that's the only difference between e-gas and turbo spark plugs?

[arronm]

Same plugs that came in my F6 only 0.7mm gap not 1.1mm

https://m.ebay.com.au/itm/GENUINE-FO...YAAOSwofxUf824

It's what was recommended. Have them in all my turbo cars

[FTE217]

Up until recently Autolite plugs were never pre gapped, especially those in the USA.
Only recently (about 2yrs ago) have Supercheap got blister packed in Double Platinum.
Those in your link not pre gapped.
IMO any decent mechanic checks plug gaps before fitting but thats me but I know donkeys are convinced whats in the pack is gapped correctly.

[solarite_guy]

I agree, you should always check the gap. These days, most are correct. What I don't like is when the plugs are gaped for one application and you need to change the gap for another. It is usually a big change.

This tends to happen when there is a change in manufacturing spec to suite a newer application.

[Maka]

What about spark plug indexing, is it worth it for hi po street cars & whats the best way? Sorry if a bit off topic lol.

Great thread subject SG!!

cheers, Maka

[arronm]

What do you think the difference is between a SK20R11 and a SK20R7
or a AGSP22YE13. AGSP22YE11 AGSP23YE09 AGSP22YE07.

It's the length of the ground electrode.

What do you think happens when the bend the ground electrode to reduce or Increase the gap. You alter the shape. Not to mention the risk of damaging the 0.4mm centre electrode.

I use to check gaps back in the day. But these days they are close to spot on out of the pack

[solarite_guy]

Originally Posted by Maka

What about spark plug indexing, is it worth it for hi po street cars & whats the best way? Sorry if a bit off topic lol.

Great thread subject SG!!

cheers, Maka

Most of the time, the biggest benefit to indexing is to keep the ground strap from getting hit by the piston.

With certain types of plugs and with certain mods to plugs, the old hot roders tale of indexing to "aim" the spark towards the where the kernal will tend to start in the region of exhaust valve(s).

That said, for race engines I always index them as in the above paragraph. For street engines, I don't bother indexing.

Thanks Maka.

Cheers

[arronm]

Originally Posted by FTE217

Up until recently Autolite plugs were never pre gapped, especially those in the USA.
Only recently (about 2yrs ago) have Supercheap got blister packed in Double Platinum.
Those in your link not pre gapped.
IMO any decent mechanic checks plug gaps before fitting but thats me but I know donkeys are convinced whats in the pack is gapped correctly.

Maybe Ford are lying. Or maybe they are just donkeys. Do you reckon they check gaps from off the shelf plugs when their mechanics install them



"This is the genuine oem iridium spark plug set to suit the BA Mk2 Falcon with 4.0 Turbo motor including FPV models

SK20R11 spark plugs come pre-gapped to 1.1mm and are a cold range high resistance plug to suit the Turbo motor"

Please send us your VIN to confirm application if unsure as there are so many plug variations it is VIN specific

[Maka]

From NGK - Should I Gap My Plugs?

September 30, 2012

A spark plugs Gap directly affects the tip temperature and the voltage necessary to fire the plug. NGK spark plugs traditionally leave the factory pre-gapped for their most popular application. However, a plug may fit hundreds of engines, from cars to golf carts. Gapping the plugs to your engine’s specifications is important to prevent pre-ignition, detonation, fouling and poor fuel economy. Even if the preset Gap matches that required by your engine, it is always good practice to physically check the Gap as it may have shifted during transportation (not all spark plugs are packaged in a way that protects the firing end ).

Gapping is not recommended on Multi-Ground plugs.


Fine Wire Plugs

Plug manufacturers typically warn against gapping Fine Wire spark plugs due to the fragile nature of their electrodes. They say a Fine Wire plug will outperform a standard spark plug, even if not properly gapped. However, NGK understands a spark plug can only operate to its optimum potential if properly gapped. Proper gapping technique should be followed with any spark plug, but special care should be taken with Fine Wire plugs. NGK will not warranty a plug who’s Center Electrode is snapped during gapping.

Modified Vehicles

Proper gapping is especially essential in modified vehicles. The ignition process is affected by increased compression, fuel type, nitrous and high output ignition systems. A plug’s Gap must be adjusted to account for these changes in engine conditions and ensure a successful ignition sequence. Opening the Gap presents a larger spark to the air/fuel mixture, maximizing burn efficiency. However, after raising compression and installing a turbo, a smaller Gap is required to ensure ignitability in the denser air/fuel mixture.

https://www.ngk.com/learning-center/...i-gap-my-plugs

The article is a oldy but still should apply today imo.

cheers, Maka

[solarite_guy]

Originally Posted by arronm

What do you think the difference is between a SK20R11 and a SK20R7
or a AGSP22YE13. AGSP22YE11 AGSP23YE09 AGSP22YE07.

It's the length of the ground electrode.

What do you think happens when the bend the ground electrode to reduce or Increase the gap. You alter the shape. Not to mention the risk of damaging the 0.4mm centre electrode.

I use to check gaps back in the day. But these days they are close to spot on out of the pack

I like when variations are supplied by the manufacturer instead of just changing the part while keeping the old number.

[solarite_guy]

Originally Posted by Maka

From NGK - Should I Gap My Plugs?

September 30, 2012

A spark plugs Gap directly affects the tip temperature and the voltage necessary to fire the plug. NGK spark plugs traditionally leave the factory pre-gapped for their most popular application. However, a plug may fit hundreds of engines, from cars to golf carts. Gapping the plugs to your engine’s specifications is important to prevent pre-ignition, detonation, fouling and poor fuel economy. Even if the preset Gap matches that required by your engine, it is always good practice to physically check the Gap as it may have shifted during transportation (not all spark plugs are packaged in a way that protects the firing end ).

Gapping is not recommended on Multi-Ground plugs.


Fine Wire Plugs

Plug manufacturers typically warn against gapping Fine Wire spark plugs due to the fragile nature of their electrodes. They say a Fine Wire plug will outperform a standard spark plug, even if not properly gapped. However, NGK understands a spark plug can only operate to its optimum potential if properly gapped. Proper gapping technique should be followed with any spark plug, but special care should be taken with Fine Wire plugs. NGK will not warranty a plug who’s Center Electrode is snapped during gapping.

Modified Vehicles

Proper gapping is especially essential in modified vehicles. The ignition process is affected by increased compression, fuel type, nitrous and high output ignition systems. A plug’s Gap must be adjusted to account for these changes in engine conditions and ensure a successful ignition sequence. Opening the Gap presents a larger spark to the air/fuel mixture, maximizing burn efficiency. However, after raising compression and installing a turbo, a smaller Gap is required to ensure ignitability in the denser air/fuel mixture.

https://www.ngk.com/learning-center/...i-gap-my-plugs

The article is a oldy but still should apply today imo.

cheers, Maka

That's a good write up Maka.

I agree, when you go racing conditions change and all aspects of an engines state of tune needs addressing. Spark plugs are an important component.