New P Plate Laws now Official - Page 4

andrewts · 12-01-2007, 07:32 PM

July 29 hopefully for me. My birthday that day.

FPV8U · 12-01-2007, 08:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by El_Poochino

Nationwide laws would be great too, I asked NSW police as a Victorian P plater do I have to obey the NSW 100kmph speed cap for P platers. One said no, one said yes. I play it safe and only do 100 but it's silly that the cops don't know what law to enforce.

No you don't have to obey the NSW rules if you have a Victorian Licence, just like Power/Weight Ratio laws don't apply to me as i have a WA licence, even though i have since moved to Victoria.

Nationwide rules would definitly be a good thing, save the confusion for us and for the police. :MrT_anim:

Van D · 12-01-2007, 08:26 PM

"3) 0 Demerit points for speeding offences - automatic suspension"

WWwwwwwoooow. If that ever comes to Vic every P plater is screwed.

Van D · 12-01-2007, 08:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 4Vman

All the driver training in the world is avaliable to you right now, go do a driving course, there's plenty around, don't use driver training as an excuse, people need to get off their butts and go do it rather than waiting for handouts, take the initiative and go take responsibility for your own ability.

Thing is, that'd be great if it all worked like that.. But not everyone *wants* to go do a drivers course.. Many think it's their right to drive, not a privilege.

Steffo · 12-01-2007, 08:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by popinfresh

Thing is, that'd be great if it all worked like that.. But not everyone *wants* to go do a drivers course.. Many think it's their right to drive, not a privilege.

And so it should be. Why should transportation be a privilege?

Interceptor · 12-01-2007, 11:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by colossus

What about 21-25 year olds? These laws only affect P1 licesnses which is the first 12 months. Only a small percentage of people would wait till they were 21-25 to get their first year p's.

believe it or not, the world extends outside your own little piece of paradise, and elsewhere, laws are being brought in that affect ALL P-platers right to the age of 25

Quote:

Originally Posted by colossus

So the laws shoudnt come in as they would prevent your ability to "pulling laps" - yep thats responsible.

maybe you should become a journalist considering your ability to misinterprate things

i was referring to the distance i'd covered as being an indication of what distances P platers/younger drivers are capable of doing

Quote:

Originally Posted by colossus

They still do more kays than first year p1 license holders.

so 3-4 k's a day and the weekly 10km shopping trip adds up to more than what a P1 can manage huh?

Quote:

Originally Posted by colossus

What the hell do Queensland stats have to do with NSW laws? Although you did just prove my point further anyway.

if you'd bothered to PAY ATTENTION you would notice that in my original post i allowed for variations by saying

Quote:

Originally Posted by Interceptor

17-25yo's make up 13%-15% of the driving population
17-25yo's are involved in 32%-36% of fatal crashes

notice how i included both Qld Transport and NSW RTA statistcs there?

and prove what point? i'd like to see the RTA's equivalent page tot he one i quoted.... i'll be suprised if it contains ALL the statistics regarding crashes

Quote:

Originally Posted by colossus

Apologise for what? For pointing out that you are incorrect regarding statistics and that you can't seem to see past your own agenda?

for your inability to pay attention to what people say, and then misinterpreting what they say to make youself look good...

untill you started whinging about what i'd said, i wasnt criticising anything you'd said, only what i'd seen elsewhere

you may have drawn your stats directly from the RTA's statisitics file, but i'd love to see thier propaganda version of things

Quote:

Originally Posted by 4Vman

That was bizzare!
Got to love it when someone who's arguing against you posts statistics that support your position!!!!

wtf? i wasnt arguing against his stats, i was providing supporting evidence to my claim that the the government can be very sparing with statistics when it suits them

nathen · 13-01-2007, 12:02 AM

i personally think its crap....screw this liberal goverment.if they are so worried about dead teens ..then bloody bring back soldiers from iraq..

all4ford · 13-01-2007, 12:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by nathen

i personally think its crap....screw this liberal goverment.if they are so worried about dead teens ..then bloody bring back soldiers from iraq..

Its actually the State Labour Government who is bringing in these laws. Either way, I agree the Federal Government should throw some money at this issue, because its the only way it is ever going to get better. Its like everything, it seems to run up to sh_t until the Federal Government takes control and then it still runs up to sh_t but you dont notice because so much money is thrown at it, results are yielded.

TEaaron · 13-01-2007, 12:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steffo

On the RTA's website, the statistics for 2005 for fatalities on the roads of drivers and their age/sex groups are as follows....

Male -

0-4: 0
5-16: 0
17-20: 17
21-25: 24
26-29: 13
30-39: 25
40-49: 19
50-59: 15
60-69: 9
70+ : 20
Unkown: 0
Total: 142

Female -

0-4: 0
5-16: 0
17-20: 6
21-25: 3
26-29: 6
30-39: 10
40-49: 6
50-59: 6
60-69: 8
70+ : 4
Unkown: 0
Total: 49

Now since I can't find 2005 population stats, I'll post the 2001 NSW stats as well, since I have 2001 Census information...

Male -

0-4: 0
5-16: 2
17-20: 28
21-25: 11
26-29: 8
30-39: 26
40-49: 14
50-59: 15
60-69: 11
70+ : 20
Unkown: 0
Total: 135

Female -

0-4: 0
5-16: 0
17-20: 2
21-25: 4
26-29: 3
30-39: 6
40-49: 9
50-59: 10
60-69: 4
70+ : 6
Unkown: 0
Total: 44

Now based on the 2001 Census, ASB stats for 2001 NSW are as follows...

Age 0-4: 422,341
Age 5-14: 891,009
Age 15-24: 845,345
Age 25-54: 2,731,604
Age 55-64: 592,394
Age 65+ : 828,475

Now since the RTA statistics differ slightly, we'll add the 5-14 and 15-24 population figures together, giving us 1,736,354. Now we add up both male and female 5-16 and 17-20 stats giving us 32. 32 is 0.0018% of 1,736,354.

Compare that to people 70+, of which 26 died in NSW in 2001 and their figure of 828,475 on the census (slightly less since it counts 65+). 0.0031% of them died. So that means, statistically, a 17 year old is a safer driver then a 70 year old.

What about the big age bracket on the census, 25-54. Adding up the RTA stats that coincide you get 106 people. 106 is 0.0038% of 2,731,604. So what's shown is that according to this (and I admit its a tad rough, a bit more detail would have been good from both sites) summary of statistics, the most dangerous group of drivers in this country are aged between 25 and 54. Goes a bit against what the Government is saying, doesn't it? Lets restrict 25-54 year old drivers to only naturally aspirated 4 cyl cars, no passengers at night, no demerit points, no handsfree and whatever else we can think of! They're most likely to kill themselves, so it needs to be done.

_

Yes let's ban 4vman from driving his clevo and still if he's 100% with that as well, going by statistics I think that's what needs to be done.

I FluXx I · 13-01-2007, 01:03 AM

I live in WA and have a WA drivers license. Im flying over to sydney in June to pick up my xr6t. Then im driving all the way back to perth.

Will these laws apply to me when im over there? Can I still drive a turbo?

Im bloody not displaying my P plates on the outside of my car. If I get pulled over il just claim ignorance.

Steffo · 13-01-2007, 01:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by I FluXx I

I live in WA and have a WA drivers license. Im flying over to sydney in June to pick up my xr6t. Then im driving all the way back to perth.

Will these laws apply to me when im over there? Can I still drive a turbo?

Im bloody not displaying my P plates on the outside of my car. If I get pulled over il just claim ignorance.

No. They only affect us misfortunate NSW Licence holders.

I FluXx I · 13-01-2007, 01:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steffo

No. They only affect us misfortunate NSW Licence holders.

Excellent!! I mean, hmmmmm thats no good

4Vman · 13-01-2007, 10:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Steffo

Why should transportation be a privilege?

Its not, public transport is freely avaliable for everyone, but driving on the roads is a responsibility, not a right.

OLDFORDNUT · 13-01-2007, 10:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by FPV8U

No you don't have to obey the NSW rules if you have a Victorian Licence, just like Power/Weight Ratio laws don't apply to me as i have a WA licence, even though i have since moved to Victoria.

Nationwide rules would definitly be a good thing, save the confusion for us and for the police. :MrT_anim:

no..
they will when you obey the law and change over to Victorian liscence within 3 months.lol

Ando_Leigh · 13-01-2007, 11:07 AM

i can see a few problems with these new laws firstly as a few have aready pointed out.
The one passanger thing means more people in boots and when a young person has some1 in the back like that they do have a tendancy to try and swerve the car so the person in the boot hits there head etc.

The second problem isthe zero points for speeding i mean 10km over you really shouldn't loose your licence for that and also alot of coppers don't take plesure in tearing up a young kids licence.

What they need to bring in is a subsidized mandatory advanced driving course. that you should have to take before going for your p's test

you can have as many hours as you want but alot of people get taught how to pass the test but not how to drive.

Steffo · 13-01-2007, 02:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 4Vman

Its not, public transport is freely avaliable for everyone, but driving on the roads is a responsibility, not a right.

In this part of the world. Unfortunately.

Interceptor · 13-01-2007, 08:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by 4Vman

Its not, public transport is freely avaliable for everyone, but driving on the roads is a responsibility, not a right.

maybe you should come up this way and try to catch a bus or a train.....