Child Support

[snap]

How do they justify the huge amounts Child Supprt Agency scalp off your pay after you pay tax. What are your thoughts on this???

[jmartin]

Its not really fair. I've been paying it now for 12 years, with 3 years to go.

[GT0132]

Originally Posted by snap

How do they justify the huge amounts Child Supprt Agency scalp off your pay after you pay tax. What are your thoughts on this???

While I agree that parents have a responsibility to pay for their childs upkeep I think the amounts that non custodial parents pay (mainly fathers) is way too steep.

My ex gets $2g a month from me being child support for 2 kids aged between 11 and 14 which is more than enough to cover my share of their food, clothing, sports reg fees...Plus I also pay half the mortgage payments on a house I no longer live in and haven't done for 2 and a half years.

I agree it sucks

[gtfpv]

ohhh dear. perhaps a shared arrangement may be better. if possible . but if not , maybe go to court and try to make sure it goes to the kids in other forms like food clothes and education expenses . sorry for the pain . i hope it all pans out. my guess is to get together with people in your situation and find the good side of it . cheers .

[Laminge]

An emotive subject of which I would gladly add to with finger pointing, but I wont, lets keep it civil as there are 2 sides to a story and I have seen my fair share of kids missing out on the basics because of the selfishness of individuals while they feast.

[snap]

Originally Posted by Laminge

An emotive subject of which I would gladly add to with finger pointing, but I wont, lets keep it civil as there are 2 sides to a story and I have seen my fair share of kids missing out on the basics because of the selfishness of individuals while they feast.

Totally agree.

[FGII-XR6]

I'm fairly sure you can have CSA take the mortgage payment into account as you are providing accomodation they will then deduct that amount from your support payments

Originally Posted by GT0132

While I agree that parents have a responsibility to pay for their childs upkeep I think the amounts that non custodial parents pay (mainly fathers) is way too steep.

My ex gets $2g a month from me being child support for 2 kids aged between 11 and 14 which is more than enough to cover my share of their food, clothing, sports reg fees...Plus I also pay half the mortgage payments on a house I no longer live in and haven't done for 2 and a half years.

I agree it sucks

[svo347]

Whilst i agree with child support, i do not agree with spousal support., I pay nearly 2G p/month, now can you honestly see it costing $500 p/week to feed/clothe a kid??

[ebxr8240]

Exactly from both sides.. I'v helped
an inlaw out heaps ..
It never seems to stop..
The children was our concern..

[GT0132]

Originally Posted by au3xr6

I'm fairly sure you can have CSA take the mortgage payment into account as you are providing accomodation they will then deduct that amount from your support payments

I have checked that out and they wont....I have no issue with paying it, in fact I have more of an issue with parents diverting money into scehmes to minimise their income to avoid paying ANY child support whatsoever...Being single and in your 40's you tend to date women in the same position as you and its frightening the number of Dad's out there paying zilch and living the rich and famous lifestyle.

[snap]

I would like to know how many parents are paying for a child they have never seen as I am. 10 years old and does not even know who I am. I was hit with child support 3 months ago and it is amazing how I have no rights. Have spent 5000 on solicitor ,800 on a DNA test and still waiting. Freaks me out.

[BIGJB]

I could write a 15 page essay on how much csa suck.
But what erks me more is the fact it is % based.
If I chose to work a labouring job and earn say 600 a week
I pay only a few hundred a month. Yet if I work in my usual field
and earn say 1300 a week all of a sudden my kids must develop
a crack habit that I am expected to fund.
Needs to be a set amount per child not this percentage crap.
What pevs me even more now though is that I have moved outside of
ozzy as I wasn't seein the kids anymore anyway. (NOT MY CHOICE)
They are now doing me on potential to earn. Even though over here
I could never earn what I was in Ozzy, but as I earned that amount for many
years well I can do it now. The dogs. GGGGGGGGGRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

[Tribal]

Originally Posted by snap

How do they justify the huge amounts Child Supprt Agency scalp off your pay after you pay tax. What are your thoughts on this???

I've been meeting my full responsibilities for over 11 years without fault and despite this, I still get treated like the bad guy every-time I am on the phone to these clowns.

The formula they use in simply screwed up and is designed to keep you down.

Firstly, they calculate everything on your pre-tax wage and then take it from your after tax wage - WTF?!
Secondly, they don't (won't) include my wife as a dependent even though my two boys that live with me are only 4 & 8.
Thirdly, the self support allowance is only 18K - this barely covers the mortgage!

I have been through change of assessment a couple of times, won the case on one occasion - which was presided over by a senior case officer, and 6 months later it was overturned by another case officer and then I was forced to pay back-pay for those 6 months...

As mentioned before, fully agree that everyone should meet their responsibilities when it comes to the kids but the absolute morons that create the rules should be put in our shoes for a while...

No wonder the ute is taking so f'n long to finish :

[gtfpv]

Originally Posted by GT0132

I have checked that out and they wont....I have no issue with paying it, in fact I have more of an issue with parents diverting money into scehmes to minimise their income to avoid paying ANY child support whatsoever...Being single and in your 40's you tend to date women in the same position as you and its frightening the number of Dad's out there paying zilch and living the rich and famous lifestyle.

if some are getting fried for doing the right thing . even if it may be too much. then how can others do the wrong thing and get away with it . ??
i'm intrigued.

[Spudz27]

Not having had to deal first hand with this, but being involved as a child/teenager, let's just say my mum and dad agreed on a set amount per month. My dad continued to pay that amount, even though my sister and I had turned 18. My sister wanted a car so mum told dad to use the child support rather than pay it directly to her.

Basically I am saying maybe an agreement between you both would work. Let's just say because mum and dad made an agreement he was paying 1/3 less than he had to. My mum's jaw used to drop when she got the letter saying how much she was entitled to, but she wasn't greedy.

[Burnout]

I payed Child Support for many a year, my indebtedness ended last December.

The ex is a business owner with 15 employees, she only managed to earn just under $15000 last year, she brought a two story house at the sea shore late last year and put a tenant in the other place.

When I first had to deal with CSA I was treated quite badly as if I was getting my just deserts, in the last few years there has been a turn around, in my experience, in my dealings with CSA.

My annual debt to CSA was in excess of 40% of my after Tax income & this has left me destitute for the last 10 years. How ever I expect that in about 10 years the 'Milky Bar Kid' will keep me in an accustomed manner...... as I while away the years.... Yes, she can lay claim to up to 80% of your Super.

[gtfpv]

Originally Posted by Burnedout

I payed Child Support for many a year, my indebtedness ended last December.

The ex is a business owner with 15 employees, she only managed to earn just under $15000 last year, she brought a two story house at the sea shore late last year and put a tenant in the other place.

When I first had to deal with CSA I was treated quite badly as if I was getting my just deserts, in the last few years there has been a turn around, in my experience, in my dealings with CSA.

My annual debt to CSA was in excess of 40% of my after Tax income & this has left me destitute for the last 10 years. How ever I expect that in about 10 years the 'Milky Bar Kid' will keep me in an accustomed manner...... as I while away the years.... Yes, she can lay claim to up to 80% of your Super.

that is horrible . how can any parent let thier son get married .

[GT0336]

I can't believe you guys are paying that much, my fiancé receives a measly $26.00 a fortnight for 2 children from her ex. It’s a joke.

[Burnout]

Originally Posted by gtfpv

that is horrible . how can any parent let thier son get married .

I have advised my two kids now 20 & 18 never to get married without a pre-nuptial agreement.

I never mention their mother to either of them, as I was busy keeping up my relationship with the kids. I had 8 hours access to my kids and made the most of these moments; there was a time when the Family Court was negative to men in a rather severe way at times.

I have not spoken to their mother in ten or eleven years.

Men do need to be careful - women get together over these things quite often at the school yard gate, you know. There is a huge amount of free legal advice concerning family law available at the school yard gate.

Regrettably, I was ambushed in this manner and never stood a chance; (a mutual female friend told me later).

[Burnout]

Originally Posted by GT0336

I can't believe you guys are paying that much, my fiancé receives a measly $26.00 a fortnight for 2 children from her ex. It’s a joke.

Mate I would suggest she is a victim of my situation in reverse - a contractor/self employed bloke can spend a lot of time 'minimising income', your girlfriend has my sympathies.

[OLDFORDNUT]

my grandkids are entitled to $28 a fortnight total, as he did not put a tax return in for 3 years, then when CSA fools chased him up about tax return he went on the dole and now pays nothing due to having the kids each second weekend

[FGII-XR6]

Originally Posted by Burnedout

I have advised my two kids now 20 & 18 never to get married without a pre-nuptial agreement.

thats so American. pre nups are not worth the paper they are written on in Australia. people here sign them but they have no legal standing in Australia

[Burnout]

Originally Posted by OLDFORDNUT

my grandkids are entitled to $28 a fortnight total, as he did not put a tax return in for 3 years, then when CSA fools chased him up about tax return he went on the dole and now pays nothing due to having the kids each second weekend

You also have my sympathies - I always paid the amount required by law & I will never deprive my kids.

In this case "Blessed be the man who lays down his car/mods/hobbies/life for his kids where ever they may be".

My kids have always deserved the best I could give them. That has always been my tenant as a parent. It's that simple really.

The Govt fails these kids in so many ways by allowing these selfish parents to get away with the things they do...... Same as the contractor/self employed person who deliberately minimises income to avoid their responsibilities to their children.

Simply unforgivable.

[Scott]

I'm not in this boat and hope never to be but I have always been shocked at what fathers are put through. My industry has an incredibly high divorce rate and I seem to talk with a disproportionate amount of divorced blokes and some of the stories just make your hands clench with rage.

Kids need to remain the #1 priority and they should be aptly cared for but Dads need care too. It is not reasonable to take a mans wife, children, dignity, home and income from him and then be suprised that he kills himself with grog, drugs or a rope - let alone bring harm to those that screwed him so badly.

Divorce is an awful thing that everyone involved suffers from - not just the woman and kids.

I'm probably preaching to the choir here but it just gets me wild with rage.

On a more positive note, a good mate of mine divorced his wife and moved out of his home and day-to-day kids lives. They sold the home, he took half the proceeds - even though it was his before they met, and he started an investment portfolio.

The funds were always there in their entirety and he was able to pay the costs they agreed upon out of his returns and a small weekly split from his wages - think $100 or so. He covered something along the lines of $X per month toward keeping a roof over the kids head and any cost directly associated with the kids. Things like all schooling, all clothes, all school trips and pocket money etc.

He was happy that he wasn't being screwed and could afford to enjoy a relatively free financial life and was even more happy that his kids knew Daddy bought me this and that - not that he was a scumbag who didn't pay for anything.

At the end of the time, his quite amiable ex-wife had maintained her lifestyle [supplemented by] hooking up with a new bloke, he had maintained his lifestyle and his kids got all they required and had a substantial safety net under them if needed.

He recently stopped paying the bills because the kids hit 18 and threw the money on to his mortgage and has come out pretty bloody well all things considered.

Reason for telling this story is simply to highlight that there is smarter ways to do things than simply raping a bloke and destroying his life. I truly hope that some innovation gets plied to the CSA in the near future and they look at smarter ways to achieve the best for the whole family.

[Burnout]

Originally Posted by au3xr6

thats so American. pre nups are not worth the paper they are written on in Australia. people here sign them but they have no legal standing in Australia

I couldn't care a 'tinkers toss' if pre nups are in statute law here in Australia.
I advised my kids to do one.

[smally289]

Yes CSA sucks!

I have had custody of my 3 boys for the past 8 years and have seen very little in the way of money from their mother. She has had good jobs, flash cars, holidays etc etc and I she still owes several thousand dollars in arrears payments. In the last 12 months I have recieved $40 in total from the CSA. They are hopeless! I bet if the shoe was on the other foot, I'd be strung up by the gonads.

Just my 2c worth ..........

[FGII-XR6]

thats your choice of course but all you are doing is giving lawyers money for a worthless piece of paper

Originally Posted by Burnedout

I couldn't care a 'tinkers toss' if pre nups are in statute law here in Australia.
I advised my kids to do one.

[snappy]

Originally Posted by au3xr6

thats your choice of course but all you are doing is giving lawyers money for a worthless piece of paper

exactly what my lawyer said. Well actually he said just give $1800 dollars it will have the same effect.

[IDT]

Originally Posted by 99GHIA

I could write a 15 page essay on how much csa suck.
But what erks me more is the fact it is % based.

So true, Some time ago I was watching that show with the woman speaking to the audience about current issues (on ABC I think), and one bloke said what I thought was extremely fair before he was cut short and ignored for the rest of the show.

Child support should be based on the average of both wages to a maximum percentage. The custodial parent gets an initial payment and to get subsequent payments only recieves replacement funds for itemised receipts of spending. Shared items such as groceries, elecricity etc are pro rata ( two kids in a house of five and its 40% of the bill). What is left of the CSA deduction goes back to the parent paying child support.

I would also add:To ensure the health of the children fast food and electronic games etc get placed on a list of non claimable items. Excessive bills "such as $20,000 school fees, trip to Italy for educational purposes" must have prior approval of both parents or the CSA review each parents arguement and makes a decision. As most families these days have both parents working, once children are of school age, parents who do not work are forced into work for the dole type activities for up to 25 hours a week to motivate them not to take advantage of the system. Finally, when the custodial parent has another adult living with them, that persons income is considered in some way.

[IDT]

Originally Posted by au3xr6

thats so American. pre nups are not worth the paper they are written on in Australia. people here sign them but they have no legal standing in Australia

Apparently that is changing, problem is CSA has god like powers and will probably be able to ignore those as they do everything else